Tuesday, August 21, 2007

I'm back!

Yup - one week of playing with family and doing rewrites in Bowral (not to mention the odd jog and a bit of pub trivia) is now over.

I'm almost through the entire manuscript and hopeful that by the end of the week I might be almost in a position to call it done!

In other news I have for the third time picked up 2nd place in the Katherine Susannah Prichard Fantasy and Science Fiction Awards!

The judge Dave Luckett said:

Although the runner-up and the other stories on the shortlist have definite merits, unlike the winner they have structural problems that cannot be overcome by editing or a minor rewrite. “The Chance” handles action and character very well, with strong narrative elements, including a working denouement, but the setting is not internally consistent. In this post-apocalyptic near-anarchy, metal would necessarily be scavenged and a set of simple machine tools and a working forge would be much-sought-after treasure trove. Someone would have found them - it’s not as though they’re hidden. For that matter, the protagonist and her brother have been actively trying to repair the railway equipment, for which they needed scrap. It’s impossible to believe that nobody has ever investigated a nearby shed large enough to contain a steam locomotive and a workshop, and it ruptures suspension of disbelief when this is demanded of the reader.

I have to say his comments on the value of scrap metal are certainly valid and I will definately be putting some greater thought into that aspect sometime soon - for the moment I am having a wry laugh. I mean what does a girl have to do to win FIRST place!


Post a Comment

<< Home